Choosing Between Assisted Living and In-Home Care in the DMV Area

How to Choose Between Assisted Living and In-Home Care the DMV Area

Assisted living is a type of residential housing that offers additional support for seniors and other adults who need assistance with activities of daily living (ADL's) but do not require the kind of around-the-clock medical care provided in a nursing home or long-term care facility.
In contrast, in-home care, or home care, involves qualified caregivers coming to the home on a pre-arranged schedule to provide the additional support a person needs to continue to live safely and comfortably at home.

Do assisted living and in-home care offer the same services?

Staff at assisted living facilities and in-home caregivers can perform many of the same services in support of an older adult. These include personal care, washing and dressing, ensuring safe mobility and medication reminders. Both can also assist with transportation to doctors and other healthcare appointments, facilitate social outings and provide companionship.

Comparison of In-home Care vs Assisted Living.

While assisted living and in-home care will be able to provide many of the same services, there are significant differences in the experience they provide that go beyond one being offered in residential housing and the other in the home. Let's take a look at some of these key differences:

Level of care needed.

Assisted Living facilities can offer higher levels of care and support. Most will provide meals, laundry and housekeeping to residents and staff are available round-the-clock to help with personal hygiene, bathing and toileting, safe mobilization and medical monitoring. Some nursing care may also be provided such as medication management and wound care. Assisted living facilities are usually governed by the licenses and laws of the State such that the environment and services offered to residents meets minimum standards but also that the overall experience of assisted living is fairly uniform across facilities and for all residents. In-home care is much more variable and flexible and can be tailored to an individual's needs and circumstances. In-home caregivers can provide almost any type of help or support in the home while home care services can be gradually introduced as the person needs them, from a couple of hours a week for help with shopping and light housework to 24hr care, even end of life care.

Safety and security.

This is a big consideration for many. Assisted living typically offer 24/7 security, emergency response systems and staff available in case of emergencies. Many also offer medical monitoring to residents with chronic illness. In general, home care cannot offer a comparable level of security and supervision and recipients of care in the home rely more on their caregivers, family and surrounding community to stay safe. Personal alarms or one of many medical alert and fall detection systems can

Social support and community.

Assisted living provides opportunity for social engagement in communal spaces where residents can meet informally, through participation in planned activities and during organized social outings. While assisted living may offer a ready-made community to residents, moving to residential housing has the potential downside of uprooting an older adult from their existing social networks and community, and may even result in less contact with family. Remaining in the home as care needs increase requires more effort to ensure socialization and maintain relationships but has the advantage that these existing relationships may be more familiar and meaningful to the person.

Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland In‑Home Care from OndeCare

In-home caregiver avatar Taiwo Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA)
Taiwo
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA)
Services
  • bathing/dressing
  • socialization/entertainment
  • house cleaning
  • medication reminders
  • + 9 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar Amanda Registered Nurse (RN)
Amanda
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Registered Nurse (RN)
Services
  • meal preparation
  • light housekeeping
  • personal care
  • transferring/positioning
  • + 15 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar LAINA Direct Support Professional (DSP)
Laina
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Direct Support Professional (DSP)
Services
  • recreational activities
  • light housekeeping
  • companionship
  • errands/excursions
  • + 21 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar Shontae Home Health Aide
Shontae
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Home Health Aide
Services
  • house cleaning
  • meal preparation
  • companionship
  • bathing/dressing
  • + 5 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar Jael Personal Care Assistant (PCA)
Jael
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Personal Care Assistant (PCA)
Services
  • bathing/dressing
  • incontinence care
  • light housekeeping
  • companionship
  • + 13 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar Bernita Personal Care Assistant (PCA)
Bernita
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Personal Care Assistant (PCA)
Services
  • safety/fall protection
  • medication reminders
  • incontinence care
  • house cleaning
  • + 18 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar Ayanna Personal Care Assistant (PCA)
Ayanna
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Personal Care Assistant (PCA)
Services
  • socialization/entertainment
  • mobility assistance
  • light housekeeping
  • safety/fall protection
  • + 14 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar Lexus Direct Support Professional (DSP)
Lexus
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Direct Support Professional (DSP)
Services
  • errands/excursions
  • companionship
  • mobility assistance
  • meal preparation
  • + 20 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar Victoria Direct Support Professional (DSP)
Victoria
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Direct Support Professional (DSP)
Services
  • bathing/dressing
  • errands/excursions
  • meal preparation
  • incontinence care
  • + 10 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar Tauheedee Personal Care Assistant (PCA)
Tauheedee
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Personal Care Assistant (PCA)
Services
  • doctors visits
  • recreational activities
  • light housekeeping
  • personal care
  • + 16 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar Maria Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA)
Maria
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA)
Services
  • mobility assistance
  • personal care
  • errands/excursions
  • catheter care
  • + 18 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar Martha Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA)
Martha
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA)
Services
  • medication reminders
  • socialization/entertainment
  • mobility assistance
  • doctors visits
  • + 18 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar Natasha Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA)
Natasha
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Certified Nursing Assistant (CNA)
Services
  • doctors visits
  • personal care
  • meal preparation
  • socialization/entertainment
  • + 15 more
COVID-19 vaccinated
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
In-home caregiver avatar Loqua Personal Care Assistant (PCA)
Loqua
Available in
Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland
Personal Care Assistant (PCA)
Services
  • catheter care
  • incontinence care
  • socialization/entertainment
  • transportation
  • + 22 more
Client transportation
BACKGROUND CHECKED
Ondecare Logo
See more fully vetted, background checked caregivers that provide in-home care for adults available in Washington DC, Northern Virginia and Maryland.

How to Choose Between In-home Care vs Assisted Living.

When an loved one or older adult starts to need care to stay safe and healthy, choosing between assisted living and in-home care is a big decision and one which very much depends on that individuals unique needs, circumstances and preferences. Make sure to consider the following:

Assess the individual's care needs: Can these be met with regular visits to the home from a qualified in-home caregiver or is around-the-clock help and supervision now required that are more effectively provided in an assisted living facility? There is no clear line between the two, however, as even 24hr care, with all required services, is available both in assisted living and from in-home caregivers working in shifts but the in-home option takes more effort to organize than in a facility.

Consider safety: As frailty increases, some older adults become at high risk of falling, others with debilitating chronic illness can suffer frequent medical emergencies while persons with dementia may try to wander, particularly at night. If being alone for any period of time is potentially unsafe, assisted living is set up to be a better solution than home care, particularly if continual supervision and monitoring is the only or main care need. Also, not all homes are suitable for aging in place, due to poor maintenance, steep stairs and other hazards and while home modifications can help, it may be easier to opt for residential care.

Individual preferences: AARP reports that over 80% of seniors want to age in place, which is possible with the use of in-home care versus turning to living in an Assisted Living facility. The comfort and familiarity of home and continued access to friends and established community all make in-home care the most desirable option for many. Individual preferneces differ however, and other older adults may appreciate the convenience and amenities offered by assisted living.

Availability of care: Access to in-home care varies with location, generally being more consistent in urban areas than more rural locations. Be sure to investigate the needed services can be reliably delivered before choosing in-home care. In contrast, while an assisted living facility can always be found, it may be some distance from the individual's family, friends and community making it difficult for them to maintain important connections.

Cost: In-home care is generally cheaper than assisted living up until more than 40 hours of care a week is required. The cost of in-home care varies with hours of care required per week as well as location and level of care. Also take into account the ongoing cost of maintaining a home and mortgage vs a facility where accommodation, maintenance and meals are usually included in the price. We dive into the cost of care in more detail below.

Caregiving Services

Respite care
Bathing & dressing
After surgery care
Alzheimer’s care
And more
Emergency care
After school care
Working from home
Date night out
And more
Back to work coverage
Nighttime nurse
Mom’s time off
Date night
And more
Respite care
Autism care
Down’s syndrome care
Child care with special needs
And more
Find a Trustworthy Caregiver for your Loved One Today with Onde Care

4.9 out of 5 stars. 
750+ Reviews.

We've served over 200 families in Northeast Ohio, D.C., Virginia and Maryland.

Maria was absolutely amazing! She instantly bonded with my father and immediately took care of his needs. She engaged him in conversation and made him feel alive and whole. She went above and beyond to care for him. She surpassed my expectations at such short notice. She's God sent and I highly recommend her to care for your loved one.

Chiquita, Washington DC, DC
Adult & Elder Care

Leigh is very friendly and conscientious. Our mom enjoys Leigh's company and we appreciate that our mom is getting excellent care.

Georgia, Chagrin Falls, OH
Adult & Elder Care

Ms. T gives great care to my boys. I am so happy that we chose each other

Andrea, Capitol Heights, MD
Child Care

Patricia is very kind and professional. My husband was comfortable with her and so was I. She is experienced and took care of my husband with planning and critical thinking. We will definitely be happy to have her return to us to provide care. Thank you.

Margaret, Euclid, OH
Adult & Elder Care

Great work! Betty is super thorough and goes above and beyond to do her best. I'll be working with Betty again!

Keri, Washington DC, DC
Adult & Elder Care

Stefana was awesome. She listened to my instructions I left to a T. She played games with my kids. Took my daughter to and from a play date. When I came in they were watching a nature show and talking about animals.

Jen, Solon, OH
Child Care

Very patient and nice. Works well with my son. Will book again in the future if available.

Talita, Odenton, MD
Special Needs Care

Aukia did a fantastic job! You can tell she has a strong education background because she took time out of the day to do some lessons with my kids, including learning the days of the week! Would absolutely book again.

Brandon, Cleveland Heights, OH
Child Care

I’m so glad Zachary had a fun day with Latonya. She was great and it really made my life easier to know he was in great hands this week.

Michelle, Montgomery Village, MD
Child Care

Artrez is wonderful! Punctual, friendly, and my kids loved him. He went above and beyond (cleaning and creating entertaining activities for the kids). Highly recommend!

Elizabeth, Lyndhurst, OH
Child Care

Toni was a great help, very patient with my Mom. Positive vibe overall. Thank you for the great work.

Tarsilla, Silver Spring, MD
Adult & Elder Care

Really appreciated her willingness to adapt to our last minute changes. Took well to the kids and assisted with care

Tina, Painesville, OH
Child Care

Anwar was amazing!

Andre, Ashburn, VA
Adult & Elder Care

Kelsey was super communicative, on time, and asked great questions to make sure she provided good care for our daughter. She definitely had a lot of experience with infants and really kept her cool when the baby was losing it.

Emily, Cleveland Heights, OH
Infant Care

Cori is great! She arrived on time, with short notice. She was very kind and patient with my child as well as my nervous pup. Super friendly, professional and helpful. Highly recommended!!

Susan, Cuyahoga Falls, OH
Child Care

Patricia is kind , caring , fun and responsible with our special needs son . He looks forward to seeing her. So happy to have met :)

Melissa, Shaker Heights, OH
Special Needs Care

OndeCare served its exact purpose for me yesterday. I woke up sick at 5.30 AM, booked Adailia at 7 AM, and she was here at 9 AM to save me (and take care of my twin infants).

Amanda, Chagrin Falls, OH
Infant Care

Shertarra was great! She is very conscientious and made herself available at very short notice, even on Christmas Day!

Marc, Orange, OH
Adult & Elder Care

Patricia is great! Very knowledgeable, kind/caring, capable, and easy to get along with - it would be hard to find anyone better.

David, Euclid, OH
Adult & Elder Care

Christina has been an absolute Godsend for us. She is doing a phenomenal job and we're actually going to see if she can help us out even more. We are more than pleased with her help!

Walter, Aurora, OH
Adult & Elder Care

Jessica is always the best ,reliable great care and excellent company.

Don, Lakewood, OH
Adult & Elder Care

Andrea was booked last minute & we really lucked out! She was warm, attentive and really made my parents feel comfortable immediately.

Amor, Mentor, OH
Adult & Elder Care

Jennifer has cared for my Mom and daughter. She is fantastic all around! She has a wonderful attitude and goes above and beyond with everything. I trust her completely to care for our family and I can't recommend her enough.

Molly, Gates Mills, OH
Adult & Elder Care

Overall I had a great experience and I am very pleased with Jaynine and I look forward to a nice working relationship. I have seen a lot of caregivers when I was in a rehab facility for three months and I am now able to judge their character, Jaynine made a great impression on me.

Olivera, Streetsboro,OH
Adult & Elder Care

Cherita did a wonderful job taking care of my Mom. She was prompt, professional and quickly learned the morning routine. She related well to my Mom and we look forward to having her come back.

Betty, Independence, OH
Adult & Elder Care

Nicole was wonderful! She was on time and understood the need for PPE. She was willing to enthusiastically do anything I asked her to do, and her medical knowledge was invaluable. Great job Nicole!!

Constance, Richmond Heights, OH
Adult & Elder Care

Chereve was fantastic with our son! She showed up early, was fantastic with my four year old when he wasn’t feeling well. My son said he loved her!

Elizabeth, Beachwood, OH
Child Care

Heaven did a phenomenal job keeping my multiple kids well taken care of the entire evening. She played with them, made dinner, and cleaned up leaving everyone and everything better than when I left!

Michelle, Chagrin Falls, OH
Child Care

Amber was great. She arrived early and immediately engaged with our girls (19 months & 5 years) and managed bath and bedtime routine. She even took the time to clean our counters and then some. I’d definitely rehire and recommend.

Sharilyn, Beachwood, OH
Child Care

Alice is becoming a fan-favorite here at Fellowship City Church! She is incredibly professional, but also very warm and welcoming. She's great with the kids, and always works well with whatever other childcare worker she is paired with. We can't wait to use her more and more in the future!

Allison, Chagrin Falls, OH
Child Care

Rae was excellent. My son was happy & had fun. She went above and beyond to help me in tasks that are challenging bc of my health when she didn’t have to do that. Very thankful to have had her help. Highly recommend!

Elizabeth, Lakewood, OH
Child Care

Marc is very upbeat and seems to be bonding well with my son. We are lucky to have him to help take care of my son 

Meghan, Chagrin Falls

Shanelle cared for my boys over the summer and consistently went above and beyond what was expected of her! Both boys are very fond of her, and I was able to work and know they were safe and well cared for - an experience we couldn't get from daycare centers. I will absolutely be looking forward to working with her more in the future!

Sarah, Cuyahoga Falls

Manny is a great companion for our son. He is very cognizant that primary caregivers get the relief they need while his client gets the attention, independence and community interaction he needs. And just a really great guy!

Kathy, Hudson, OH

Tracee has been great with our grandson. She is kind, patient, and very calming for his energy. She is reliable and very good with him. He likes spending time with her

Emma, Olmsted, OH

Lee has done everything that I have asked of her and now I can breathe when my son, who has special needs, and requires constant monitoring for his medical condition is in her care. I can trust lee with his life.

Julie, Akron, OH
Special Needs Care

Our four girls loved Aukia. She was fantastic and helped us out for portions of 8 days over a 2-week period. Very calm and comforting demeanor and engaging with the kids. Was always early. We would highly recommend Aukia and look forward to seeing her again.

David, Shaker Heights, OH
Child Care

Trusted by Our Partners

Portage DD logo We Care, You Care logo. The Ben Rose Foundation University Hospitals, Cleveland logo Summit DD logo Milestones Autism Resources logo Senior Care Authority logo